Click here to stay informed with FREE Email updates!

Georgia Heritage Council - dedicated to actively preserving and restoring our great heritage.
Click here for more info on Campaign 2006Click here for more info on our Heritage Database

Click here to Contribute to the Georgia Heritage Council!

HOME  || About GHC  || Campaign 2006  || Commentary  || Links & Info  || Membership  || Press Releases  || X-Files

Click here for current News & Info

Click here for the history and status of the Litigation against the Augusta Taliban

The Dukes of Heritage VS. The Dorks of Hotlanta--click here for more!

HOT Links

Aw Shucks!
ChristianCitizens.org
Confederate Heritage Month
Dixie Internet.com
Dixie Rising.com
Dustin Inman Society
Elect Mike Crane
Georgia Division SCV
GeorgiaFirst.org
GA Flag Referendum.org
GA General Assembly
LetGeorgiaVote.com
League of the South
Let Us Vote!
RobertLloyd.net
Sons of Confederate Veterans (IHQ)
SCV Army Of Tennessee
Southern Heritage News & Views
Southern Heritage PAC
Southern Messenger
Southern Party of GA
TerryWarren.net
More Links

BOSS SONNY BOY: Hear the Parody song MP3 that's sweeping Georgia!!

SECRET CHAMBER MAN: Hear the Parody song MP3 that's sweeping Georgia!!

Click here for the Panhandlers of Atlanta

Georgia's Three Stooges: Moe Richardson, Larry Johnson, Curley Perdue

News Archives

June 2007 News

May 2007 News

April 2007 News

March 2007 News

February 2007 News

November 2006 News

October 2006 News

September 2006 News

August 2006 News

May 2006 News

April 2006 News

March 2006 News

February 2006 News

A new Smash Hit song sweeping Georgia!  Click here for the lyrics and music!

Help SPREAD THE MESSAGE - click here for info

Southern Heritage Car Tag for all Georgians--click for more info!

79% of Georgia's believe GA should have a Fair Vote
79% of Georgians want a
Fair Vote

Attention All Georgia Heritage Supporters!

The Official State Signs for Georgia - click for more info
Official Georgia State Signs

EMAIL THIS    PRINT THIS

Rebels with a Cause - Letter by Lewis Regenstein

April 24, 2005
LETTERS

'The Confederate Battle Flag';
Rebels With a Cause
To the New York Times Editor:

According to Diane Mc- Whorter's review of John M. Coski's book, ''The Confederate Battle Flag'' (April 3) [see below], the author ''points out that the 'Heritage, Not Hate' flag advocates are engaged in a futile exercise when they try 'to divorce the defense of Confederate symbols and the honor of Confederate soldiers from the cause for which the soldiers fought.' ''

My more than two dozen maternal ancestors who fought for the South made it clear, in their letters, memoirs and books, what that Lost Cause was: they were fighting for their homeland -- not for slavery, but for their families, homes and country.

Put simply, most Confederate soldiers felt that they were fighting because an invading army from the North was trying to kill them and burn their homes and cities. Your reviewer implicitly acknowledges this, writing that ''the North's scorched-earth war strategy was indeed designed to annihilate not just the South's army but its entire civilization.''

In contrast, my ancestor Maj. Raphael Jacob Moses was forbidden by his commander, Robert E. Lee, even to enter private homes in search of supplies in raids into Union territory, to carry out his duties as commissary officer charged with feeding and provisioning 40,000 soldiers.

The Confederate soldiers, often exhausted and hungry, sick and shoeless, wet and cold, outnumbered and outsupplied but rarely outfought, showed amazing courage, honor and valor, enduring terrible hardships and overwhelming, even hopeless odds. That is why so many decent Southerners are proud of their ancestors, and their symbols. They may have lost the war, but they never lost their honor.

LEWIS REGENSTEIN, Atlanta

Lewis Regenstein, a native Atlantan, is a writer and author. {regenstein@mindspring.com}


April 3, 2005 -- New York Times

'The Confederate Battle Flag': Clashing Symbols
By DIANE MCWHORTER
THE CONFEDERATE BATTLE FLAG
America's Most Embattled Emblem.
By John M. Coski.

Illustrated. 401 pp. The Belknap Press/ Harvard University Press. $29.95.

THROUGHOUT its history of controversy, one thing the Confederate battle flag has consistently stood for is the tendency of human beings to muddle their best instincts and their worst. As the banner of Southern nationalism, the star-spangled cross is an emblem of heroic self-determination, of the Confederacy's rebellion against federal ''oppression.'' But the ideal that urged the secessionists on to their blood-drenched sacrifice was the freedom to subject a race of people to enslavement.

Nearly a century and a half after the Civil War ended, the battle flag remains a standard in the eternal struggle between tradition and change, a conflict that is looking increasingly like a culture war. The most protracted ''flag flaps'' have been sparked by the campaigns of African-Americans, along with sympathetic whites, to compel Southern states to purge from their official insignia an icon widely seen as the badge of white supremacy. The subject is so inflammatory that Howard Dean's overture to voters with Confederate flags on their pickup trucks during his presidential campaign set off a cross-fire of recrimination and bad faith. John M. Coski's history, ''The Confederate Battle Flag,'' brings some needed rationality to a debate driven by the raw emotion of soul injury.

But reason, it turns out, is unequal to ''the duality of the Southern thing'' -- as the dialectics of Southern identity is called by Drive-By Truckers, contemporary rock's interpreters of Dixie. It takes more magic than is attempted by this academic study to conjure a region that balances so many polar extremes -- generous hospitality and casual violence, rebellious individualism and docile conformity, scrappy sectionalism and hyperpatriotism, military discipline and warrior impulsivity, redneck pride and genteel modesty -- all under a flag claimed equally by the Ku Klux Klan and the liberators of Soviet-bloc Europe.

The battle flag exemplified this duality from the beginning. It was embraced as a belligerent alternative to the original official flag of the Confederacy, the Stars and Bars, which blood-lusty rebels condemned as a ''servile imitation'' of the North's Stars and Stripes. Yet its signature cross was positioned diagonally in order not to alienate the South's Jewish citizens through overt Christian symbolism. In the post-bellum decades of segregation, when black voices were excluded from civic discourse, the two competing camps of flag protocol were the ''correct use'' purists, dedicated to the sacred honor of the Confederate dead, and the admen, frat boys and politicians who believed the image belonged to the popular culture. It was not until 1948 that the flag resurfaced in connection with a white-supremacist political movement, the Dixiecrats, those Southern Democrats who bolted their party in protest against its civil rights program.

As useful as it is to have the record set straight on, say, the fact that the Klan did not take up the Confederate colors until the 1940's, too much of this book is a catalog of flag moments, with an elusive organizing principle and scant sociopolitical context. When Coski, the historian at the Museum of the Confederacy in Richmond, Va., does sally forth from the thicket of Southern-crossed Klan rallies, segregation fests, football games, Old South balls, stock car races and military operations (he informs us that some marines signaled the American victory on Okinawa during World War II by raising the Confederate flag), the analysis is refreshingly direct and nonpolemical, especially on the merits of the various controversies. Coski points out that the ''Heritage, Not Hate'' flag advocates are engaged in a futile exercise when they try ''to divorce the defense of Confederate symbols and the honor of Confederate soldiers from the cause for which the soldiers fought.'' But he likewise tweaks the opponents for their excesses of historical revisionism: ''Elected officials, community leaders and intellectuals must cease encouraging the untenable belief that there is an inherent American right not to be offended.''

Coski's unsentimental approach is admirable, but by slighting the emotional essence of the ''Southern thing'' he sidesteps the basic, tragic question: Why are so many white people so irrationally invested in their regional mythology? However inept the flag's defenders are at articulating it, the reason does in fact transcend race. The South's ferocious sectional pride is the flip side of an inferiority complex, a chip-on-the-shoulder legacy of its savage defeat by a civilization it rejected long before the Civil War. Consider the South's antebellum obsession with the ''lost cause'' of Scotland's struggle for independence against cold, mercantile England. In his fascinating study of vanquished nations, ''The Culture of Defeat,'' Wolfgang Schivelbusch describes how this romance of the underdog reflected the agrarian Southern cavaliers' doomed sense of obsolescence when confronted with the inexorable moneymaking machines of the North. (The Confederacy's Southern cross was actually the cross of St. Andrew, Scotland's patron saint.) The North's scorched-earth war strategy was indeed designed to annihilate not just the South's army but its entire civilization. As the Union general Philip Henry Sheridan declared, ''The people must be left nothing but their eyes to weep with over the war.''

The South has long expressed its grief through unconstructive displays of resentment. According to Drive-By Truckers: ''We ain't never gonna change. / We ain't doin' nothin' wrong.'' In 2001 white Mississippians voted overwhelmingly to preserve the Southern cross on their state flag (just as, in a grosser act of nobody-can-tell-us-what-to-do defiance nearly 50 years earlier, local jurors acquitted the coldblooded murderers of the black teenager Emmett Till).

The perversely empowering allure of victimhood calls out even to the South's most critical daughters. Some years ago, I was looking into a potential elementary school for my younger child. It was a highly recommended prospect, located on the politically correct Upper West Side of Manhattan and named after one of General Sheridan's colleagues. Halfway through the school's guided tour, I decided ''no way,'' explaining to a fellow Southern mom who was there, ''Do you really think you could tell the folks back home that you're sending your child to the William Tecumseh Sherman School?''

Such are the dwindling stakes of the continuing North-South conflict, a clash of values nowadays defined in terms of blue states and red states. As with most of the issues in the culture wars, the battle over the Confederate flag may bring moral satisfaction to the victors, but little in the way of improvement to their daily lives. Fighting over the spoils of a tattered cloth is another example of ordinary people taking passionate political stands that distract them from the likelier source of their distress, the widening division not between whites and blacks but between have-mores and have-lesses.

Diane McWhorter is the author of ''Carry Me Home. Birmingham, Alabama: The Climactic Battle of the Civil Rights Revolution,'' and a young adult history of the civil rights movement, ''A Dream of Freedom.''

EMAIL THIS    PRINT THIS

Copyright © 2003-2008, GeorgiaHeritageCouncil.org
Georgia Heritage Council | P-6 2363 North Cliff Colony Drive
Gainesville, GA 30501 | Phone: 770.297.4788
Email:   chairman@GeorgiaHeritageCouncil.org

Latest Commentary

Who Media serves?

Remembering Respect

Christmas Rememberance

Make English official

Dealing with Cowardice

Liberty Lost Part 8

Pledge Part III

Pledge Part II

Pledge Part I

Battle of Atlanta

Libertarians vs. SoCons

Live Earth Noise

Patriots & Gift Horses

Gettysburg July 4th

Independence Day 2007

Battle Hymn Falsehoods

Green Card Fraud

Kennesaw Mtn Women

Oaky Woods festers

Remembering Fathers

Rose of Socialism (pt.3)

Republic's Tombstone

Rose of Socialism (pt.2)

Rose of Socialism (pt.1)

The New Slave Traders

Is 'Scamnesty' dead?

GA Corruption Leader?

A Bibliophile confesses

Random Thoughts...

Bell Tolls for US

Amnesty Lies

Jefferson Davis What-ifs

Taxpayer funded hate

Jefferson Davis' Bday

Memorial Day tribute

GOP revisionism

Tolerance, kindness & ...

Chambliss must go!

Frankly on Work Ethic

Rebutting Boteach's BS

Hate loses in Canada

Hate on Campus

Davis' Memorial Day Funeral Train

History Pendulum

Liberty Lost part 7

Hyatt's Hokum on '56 flag

Liberty Lost part 6

Liberty Lost part 5

How dare they...

Confederate Day prayers

Wisdom v. Democracy

God & Evil

Roswell Mills Tragedy

Hysterical Channel 2

Making Truth a Crime

Sherman's March & you

Important Message

Mt. Zion City Flag

3rd Revolution - Part 2

Memorial Day in Dixie

Anger Management

Captain Sally Tomkins

Great Locomotive Chase

3rd American Revolution

Easter Devotional 2007

Ready for Reparations?

Coke's CSA roots

Constitutional concerns

Arlington Nat'l Cemetery

Tide is Turning?

Perdue right...so far

Doomed to repeat?

April is Confederate History Month

I told you so

Lies spewed at UGA

History month needed?

McNaughton's Nonsense

NAACP distortions

Eric Johnson, architech of heritage destruction

Lincoln Hypocrisy

Apologies, let's be clear

Slavery, Apologies & Duty

Dway dese guys tok

On Slavery Apologies

Madison vs. Govt Secrecy

Liberty Lost (part4)

Speak Southern

Reporting Illegals

Last C.S.A. Order

Absurd Slavery Apologies

Our Govt., the Shepherd

Causes of Uncivil War

Enemies Within

We failed to keep it

Our Enemy the State

Breach of Oath

Black History Month Series

The 2 Parties Stink!

Worst Anti-Jewish Action

Standing Against Lies

Historical Revisionists

Sonny's land scandals

Failed Policy Continues

A Breach of Trust

Sonnygate?

Battleflags worldwide

2nd National Flag
& Young's Hypocrisy


Flags honor military

Veterans and Flags

Riverwalk Much More than a 'Flag Fight'

Riverwalk trial update

More Commentary

Latest News

SCV Press Release - April 20th

SCV Press Release - April 9th

Cleburne Co. AL Flag

SCV Press Release - April 14th

GA Sen. Isakson promotes Amnesty

SCV Press Release - Obama

SCV Press Release - NAACP

Riverwalk Appeal

Perdue Flagged in Perry

SCV Salutes American Veterans at VAMC

Perdue Flagged at Oconee

Riverwalk legal response

Augusta Lawsuit Filed!

Mason-Dixon Poll

GA Flag Referendum Issue 2

Southern Heritage Car Tags for ALL Georgians

GA Flag Referendum

Latest Parody

Transporting Promises

3 Amnesty Amigos

News from May 5, 2021

Cagle Cracks Joke

Apology Express

Bush fails to see

Oaky Woods Protest

Boss Sonny Boy

Sonny's Nightmare

Another Nightmare

Scary Mary thoughts

B.S. Oaky Woods Score

B.S. Moonshine

Whopper Competition

Secret Chamber Man

Gon' Need Taxbreaks

Boss Sonny Did!

Swampy Sign Dump

Taliban Bob Young wins
Bloody Scimitar Award


B.S. & Augusta Taliban

B.S. swampland 4 Sale

Put GA 1st: Punt Perdue

Gordon endorses McBerry

Ralph Reed DejaVu

Gen. Lee OR Maj. Lie

Republican Guard Denials

B.S. & Presidente Fox

GA Supports GOP...

Legislative Output 2006

Beware Lies of March

Reed denies....

Can't Get No Legislation

Good, Bad & Ugly

Flying Whopper One

3 Liars in Town

The YellaDog Fella

B.S. image consultant

Reed's Cash Laundry

New Sheriff in Town

Whopper Olympics

Whopper Olympics history

Comparing Day & Night

Proud Republican?

Funeral Crashers

Sonny's Valentine

Honest Glenn & GOP agenda

Can You Spot the 2?

Gold Dome Gnomes

New "Ethics" System

Perdue Medal of Dishonor

Pimps of HOTOWN

Dixie Fishing Hole

Voting Rights in 2031

B.S. at Walmart

History Quiz

Dixie Aquarium?

B.S. brags on Major Lie

Capitol Talk (part 2)

Capitol Talk (part 1)

B.S. Perdue's Future

CONTROL Agent 86

Gold Dome Nursing Home

Dirty Dubya Outspends

New B.S. slogan

B.S. in backroom 2

B.S. in backroom

B.S. Defuels Gen. Lee

Uncle Mike's Dream

Atlanta Panhandlers

Reed Flip Flops

Ralphie, casino dancer

Perdue Ethics a joke

Sonny's Secrecy Forecast

Sonny Lied: the Official Georgia State Sign

Immigration Amnesty Shuffle

Perdue the Backstabber

Augusta Taliban clears Riverwalk

A Night in the Mansion

Bad News at the Coca-Cola Board Meeting

Atlanta's Village Idiots

More X-files