|




|
|

EMAIL THIS
PRINT THIS

Steven Harrell
|
Steven Harrell has practiced law in Perry,
Georgia since 1989. He is the author of The Unionist, A Novel of the Civil War and The Rifle Captain, A Novel
of World War I. Both are available at Publish America.com, Amazon.com, and Barnes&Noble.com. You may view his weekly column at
www.StevenHarrell.com.
|
Sonnygate? - Perdue, O'Neal caught with britches down -- Commentary by Steven W. Harrell
In 2004, Governor Sonny Perdue and his sister sold land in Bonaire, Georgia along
Georgia Highway 96 to Jerry Stoker’s development group. Sonny’s portion of the proceeds were
around 2.9 million dollars.
In December of 2004, Sonny Perdue did a property exchange, by purchasing 20 acres of
land in Osceola County, Florida along a new toll road leading into Walt Disney World. This
property will skyrocket in value in the near future. The property was purchased from Newnan
developer Stanley Thomas. The land was bought from Thomas by the governor sight unseen.
The governor appointed Stanley Thomas to the state Economic Development Board. One of
Thomas’s companies, Fourth Quarter Properties, donated $250,000 to the state Republican party.
The GOP regularly runs campaign ads at its expense urging Georgia voters to reelect
Sonny Perdue as Governor of Georgia. That in and of itself lends an air of impropriety into this
deal, but there is even more to it than that.
On February 16, 2005, Representative Larry O’Neal, the governor’s floor leader,
introduced HB 488. Section 14 of HB 488 strikes the following paragraph from O.C.G.A. § 48-
7-27:
“When, on the sale or exchange of real or tangible personal property located in this state,
gain or loss is not recognized because the taxpayer receives or purchases similar property, the
nonrecognition shall be allowed only when the property is replaced with property located in this
state except for the sale or exchange of a personal residence in which case the nonrecognition
shall apply if the taxpayer purchases another personal residence anywhere in the United States
within the time allowed under the applicable provisions of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986.”
Because this subsection of O.C.G.A. § 48-7-27 was repealed by HB 488, Governor
Perdue realized over a $100,000 savings on his state capital gains taxes on the Florida real estate
transaction. What is even more bogus is the way this legislation was passed.
Section 27 of HB 488 states that most sections of the Act were to become effective on
July 1, 2005. The bill was signed into law by the governor on April 12, 2005. It was sent to the
governor by the General Assembly on April 11, 2005, which means the governor signed this bill
with lightning-like speed.
Why did he do this? Well, look at the effective date of the portion of the bill that enacts
the capital gains tax shelter.
Section 27 of HB 488 allows sections 14 and 9 of the Act, (which were to benefit the
governor on his land deal), to become law retroactively back to January 1, 2004. By making the
law apply retroactively, the General Assembly gave a big tax break to Governor Perdue’s land
deal, which occurred in December of 2004.
Several legislators wondered who was benefitting from the unusual retroactive tax law
that Larry O’Neal got the General Assembly to pass last year. Now we know who benefitted
from the law, and how much he benefitted dollar wise. This little piece of convenient legislation
proves once again that the rich and the influential make the public business a way to get more out
of the private trough. Democrats, including Representative DuBose Porter, have filed a
complaint over this little affair with the State Ethics Commission, and rightfully so.
Representative Larry O’Neal, when contacted about this convenient piece of legislation he
authored, indicated that it was not drafted to benefit Governor Perdue, his friend, in any way.
One only has to look at the actual legislation, and the land deal time line of events to see
that this statement is nothing less than a falsehood. The governor’s office has also defended the
propriety of this land deal in Florida. The problem with O’Neal’s argument and the governor’s
argument is that a paper trail clearly exists concerning the timing of the legislation, and when it
was enacted into law and signed. The actual circumstances of the enactment and signing of the
legislation makes liars out of the players involved. If it was not meant to benefit the governor,
then why put the effective date of the legislation as a retroactive date? That is almost unheard of
by the General Assembly. It is also probably illegal and unconstitutional as well.
Usually, it takes weeks and months for the governor’s counsel to study bills passed by the
General Assembly, and for the governor’s counsel to give him the green light to either sign, veto,
or line item veto a specific piece of legislation. It is really interesting that a particular bill that
gives the governor a $100,000 tax benefit is signed into law less than one day after it was passed
by the General Assembly. He couldn’t sign it into law fast enough.
You must remember that if a particular transaction looks fishy, and smells fishy, then it
must indeed be fishy. Larry O’Neal and Governor Perdue may think they really pulled a fast one
off on the people of Georgia, but it looks like this time they got caught with their britches down.
Steven Harrell has practiced law in Perry,
Georgia since 1989. He is the author of The Unionist, A Novel of the Civil War and The Rifle Captain, A Novel
of World War I. Both are available at Publish America.com, Amazon.com, and Barnes&Noble.com. You may view his weekly column at
www.StevenHarrell.com.
Related Links
How tax law saved Perdue $100,000 - ajc.com
Who did it? Sonny Did! - X-Files
Perdue quip about tax break draws Democratic criticism - AP
Perdue bought Ga. land; deal seemingly at odds with statement on conflict of interest - macon.com
Perdue invests close to home: Governor appears to ignore his rationale in Florida deal - ajc.com
Perdue bought Georgia land before Florida land controversy - AP
Sonny Flip Flops Again - J.A. Davis
Voter Choice in Georgia - spofga.org
Liberty Lost (part 3) - J.A. Davis
It's Time for a CHANGE - Ad Infinitum - J.A. Davis
It's Time for a CHANGE - J.A. Davis
Forget Party! Vote for REAL Conservatives - J.A. Davis
Confusing 'Republican' and 'conservative' - J.A. Davis
Citizens Arise, but when? - J.A. Davis
Separating the Wheat from the Chaff - J.A. Davis
The Panhandlers of Atlanta - X-Files
Republicans have abandoned small government. Why shouldn't voters abandon them? - Brendan Miniter
Sonny's Non-Sunny Forecast: A severe Secrecy Front - X-Files
Contact: Telephone 770 297-4788 P-6, 2363 North Cliff Colony Drive Gainesvlle,
GA 30501
EMAIL THIS
PRINT THIS
|
Copyright © 2003-2008, GeorgiaHeritageCouncil.org
Georgia Heritage Council | P-6 2363 North Cliff Colony Drive
Gainesville, GA 30501 | Phone: 770.297.4788 Email: chairman@GeorgiaHeritageCouncil.org
|



|